Dark Rhetoric Series – Ad Hominem: How Ego Replaces Evidence
Download MP3When logic fails, ego often steps in. In this episode, we explore the ad hominem attack — the rhetorical sleight of hand that targets a person instead of their ideas. By shifting focus from argument to identity, manipulators trade truth for dominance, and discourse for dismissal. Recognizing this move is the first defense against its power.
🔑 Key Takeaways
- Ad hominem attacks divert attention from ideas to individuals, collapsing dialogue into conflict.
- Personal attacks reveal insecurity and fear of engagement, not strength of argument.
- Truth-seeking requires discipline to address ideas, not egos.
💬 Featured Quotes
- 0:00:07 — “Ad hominem attacks really just mean to attack the person rather than the idea you’re discussing.”
- 0:00:24 — “Whoever is doing this attack will try to invalidate their opponent without actually dealing with the subject.”
- 0:00:41 — “They’ll go after character — they’ll say, ‘You have things in your background that delegitimize your right to an opinion.’”
- 0:01:10 — “It’s a way of avoiding the argument altogether while pretending to have won it.”
🔗 Explore Related Episodes
- Dark Rhetoric Series – Gatekeeping: How Power Hides Behind Standards
Examines how control hides behind selective inclusion and the illusion of authority. - Dark Rhetoric Series – Tone Policing: How Control Masquerades as Civility
Explores how the demand for calmness can be weaponized to suppress authenticity. - Barefoot in the Lodge
Reflects on vulnerability and humility as antidotes to defensiveness and egoic control.
Dynamic Inserts
Creators and Guests
Host
Brian Mattocks
Host and Founder of A Mason's Work - a podcast designed to help you use symbolism to grow. He's been working in the craft for over a decade and served as WM, trustee, and sat in every appointed chair in a lodge - at least once :D
